Rated R for language.
Family farms are fading away. Farmers are going broke. Corporations have taken over agriculture. So what is a small farm community to do to survive? Not many options. It’s easy to have high principles about the land and American (Midwestern) rural values, but at the expense of starvation and bankruptcy? Tough call, that.
Former Iowan Steve Butler (Matt Damon) and Sue Thomason (Frances McDormand) arrive in town with a solution: natural gas. Not sure how to pay your bills? Afraid to lose your land? Just sign here and the drilling company will do their business and you will be saved and make millions.
Steve and Sue seem to be saying, “We are from Free Enterprise System and we are here to help you.” At a town meeting, however, some octogenarian (Hal Holbrook), a former engineer from Boeing who moved to Small Town, America to retire and teach science, messes with Matt and Sue’s nearly completed slam dunk sales project. He points out that fracking has killed animals and poisoned water sources. And then comes along Dustin Noble (Josh Krasinski) espousing the environmentalist gospel, just as smooth (perhaps smoother) a salesman as is Steve, but intent on scaring the town folk with pictures of dead cows and sob stories about losing his family farm in Nebraska due to Steve and Sue’s company. Steve keeps saying, “I’m not a bad guy” and with Matt Damon’s face, who is to dispute? And he is able to remind them all that he is one of them — his hometown in Iowa vanished because it did not grasp the brass ring from a friendly company simply wanting to provide a mutually beneficial solution to a nearly impossible problem. Despite the solid acting and not-awful script, this is a controversial subject. It still makes Big Business mega-evil. It does provide some shades of gray (no literary pun intended) to the good versus bad arguments of fracking and using gas rather than foreign oil but we clearly know which side the film makers stand. Corporations have cheated people for generations to achieve a quick profit. “The people” are not really stupid; they simply deceive themselves on the hope of survival — of winning the lottery. They allow stupidity to possess them in order to make the fear go away … even irrationally and temporarily.
The Left Wing and Environmentalists will rejoice. The Right Wing and Big Business will cry “foul” over “Promised Land.” And note that the title of the film is not “Promise Land” but “Promised” land. Wink, wink, readers … there is meaning in that there title. I will put the politics aside and declare that I have some problems with the film unconnected to the debate. I love Frances McDormand and Matt Damon’s chemistry. They needle each other, usually Steve getting the worst of it. That was fun to watch. But, Steve is supposed to be a former Iowa farm boy, but he can’t drive a stick shift? Really? The film is way too long. And by trying to achieve some bucolic but humble atmosphere it lacks snap. It made me kind of sad, this depiction of rural life. Maybe environmental ruination isn’t so bad if life like that is the way it is depicted in “Promised Land.” Some of that was intentional, of course. The town’s people are a bit too noble … but yet they keep signing the leases. All of that seems a bit incongruent to me. At some point Sue and Steve are shunned by nearly the entire town except for one village idiot — but we see families sign the leases. There is a disconnect there; it made the plot hard to grasp. Hal Holbrook is brought along for wisdom and gravitas but after a strong start his character fades out to a rather wooden and wimpy conscience for Steve. And there lies the problem, under the surface, I might pun, with the film. It fades away — unresolved — without a clear understanding of the fracking point of this film. “Promised Land” strikes only two and a half bow ties out of five.
- On the Screen
Raw, emotional realism elevates '12 Years"
“12 Years a Slave”
Rated R for violence/cruelty, some brief nudity and brief sexuality.
Charismatic quartet bring charm to 'Vegas'
Rated PG-13 on appeal for sexual content and language.
'The Counselor' embraces complexity
Rated R for graphic violence, some grisly images, strong sexual content and language.
Rivers Alive focuses on Lake Oconee, cleans up
Each year during the cleanup, the volunteers pick up some very unusual items around Lake Oconee. This year’s unusual items included a dead buck deer minus its head.
'Carrie' fails to stand out, redundant
Rated R for bloody violence, disturbing images, language and some sexual content.
'Captain Phillips' highlights disparity
Rated PG-13 for sustained intense sequences of menace, some violence with bloody images and for substantial use of drug use.
'Gravity' stuns visually, pales mentally
Rated PG-13 for intense perilous sequences, some disturbing images and brief strong language.
'Don Jon' uses testosterone for laughs
Rated R for strong graphic sexual material and dialogue throughout, nudity, language and some drug use.
'Prisoners' is intense, thrilling and well-acted
Rated R for disturbing violent content including torture, and language throughout.
'Insidious Chapter 2' tries to cash in on predecessor's success
“Insidious Chapter 2”
Rated PG-13 for intense sequences of terror and violence and thematic elements.
- More On the Screen Headlines
- Raw, emotional realism elevates '12 Years"